I bow to your superior knowledge, but surely it's just a very flat surface running on another very flat surface.
How would there be any difference between each seal?
Yes, I've been thinking about this.
I was always taught that you can't mix and match because they were manufactured as a pair and lapped in to each other. I suspect though (as with most things in my industry) it's a little outdated. Modern machining is easily capable of turning out sufficiently identical items to be able to mix and match.
I've only tried it once due to a lack of spares. It worked, but not for long - although this might have been due to other factors.
If it's working, great!
And my knowledge isn't always that superior.
