You say no soap, no jelly ... so just oil?
Soooo, no reaction until you add more catalyst and methanol.
If you can recall what you added, I'd just sling the balance in and see what happens.
To follow on from the jam jar test, had you have had jelly, if that converts just add methanol and catalyst until you notice a change from a thick sort of yellow ochre to a dark brown, less viscous liquid.