Biopowered - vegetable oil and biodiesel forum

Biodiesel => Biodiesel equipment => Topic started by: Soft top on August 29, 2014, 03:36:54 PM

Title: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Soft top on August 29, 2014, 03:36:54 PM
I want to pump bio with a tam 105 from a tank in a basement room up to street level. Then to car via meter and hose.
The pipe from pump to meter will be about 5 meters long.
Should it be black iron or is copper ok?

Also, I will be using a nozzle with auto cut off. Can anyone recommend a bypass valve to use?
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Julian on August 29, 2014, 05:15:18 PM
I used PE water pipe ... http://www.biopowered.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,1190.0.html

Been in for over a year and no problems what so ever.  Far easier and cheaper the black iron or copper, but DON'T used the connectors with O rings.  If you hunt around you can find 25mm compression fittings with metal inserts ... BES will do them.

The Merlett Polipo PU lined hose which I used to connect the storage tank to the dispensing nozzle and is supposed to be bio resistant, leaks like crazy at the hose tails ... can't workout why, but the PU water pipe compression joints are perfect.

Some of the vane type diesel transfer pumps have a built in bypass which relieves pressure when the nozzle is closed.  Mine is of this type by the bypass only allows a small flow so I fitted a pressure switch too.  If you do this you need a non return valve so the pump builds and retains pressure on the switch.  The switch is a very one I had kicking around, made by Bailey and Mackie Ltd, I'd guess they are no longer in production, so can't help in that respect.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Soft top on August 29, 2014, 06:11:19 PM
I have 6 metres of old 1" copper the thick walled stuff and I also have loads of fittings for it so was hoping to use that but I thought I had heard somewhere that copper should not be used with bio. I know that some people use copper cylinders for processors and my processor has copper pipes but the bio does not stay in them for long.
With what I am building a lot of the pipework will still be full of bio when I turn the pump off. I don't really want to mess around draining it all every time I use it.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: K.H on August 29, 2014, 06:16:08 PM
Black iron, as you say copper reacts over time leaving a green slime
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: greasemonkey on August 29, 2014, 06:52:04 PM
I don't know so much about bio, but at least with veg, I find that if the veg is left in the pipe, it's fine. It's when it emptys and fills all the time, that the green slime builds up.
Probably best going for the iron any how, your on the safe side then.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: willbuild on August 29, 2014, 07:00:01 PM
Given the choice, I agree with julian. plastic with compression fittings with inserts. Its also more flexible, quick and simple to alter or repair and prop cheaper
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Soft top on September 15, 2014, 07:25:23 PM
Before rushing out to buy iron or plastic pipe and fittings I thought of trying an experiment.

11 days ago I put a copper fitting into some bio and also a copper fitting into some wvo.
In the picture the wvo on the right started turning green within a day and now is very green and if I lift out the fitting it has slime on it.
The bio in the centre has a very very slight hint of green after 11 days.
The jar on the left contains bio from the same batch as centre jar but with nothing in it so colours can be compared.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: julesandtash on September 15, 2014, 07:44:25 PM
The Merlett Polipo PU lined hose which I used to connect the storage tank to the dispensing nozzle and is supposed to be bio resistant, leaks like crazy at the hose tails ... can't workout why, but the PU water pipe compression joints are perfect.

Mine started to leak recently at the end where the hose tail for the nozzle is fixed into it.
I just cut off six inches of hose, refitted the tail and all is fine again.

I wonder if the jubilee clip damages the PU liner?
Interestingly the other end, which also has a hose tail into a 3/4" valve but never moves is fine, only the end which is always being flexed near the nozzle started to leak
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Tony on September 15, 2014, 07:46:26 PM
Iron pipe is cheaper per meter than copper now, but this assumes you have a die kit.  The plastic HEP2O water pipe is surprisingly resilient to bio, I've had some for seven years that has had hot bio pumped through it regularly and it is completely fine - I would go for that personally.  But as observed use inserts with compression fittings rather than the pushfit fittings themselves.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Julian on September 15, 2014, 08:08:51 PM
The Merlett Polipo PU lined hose which I used to connect the storage tank to the dispensing nozzle and is supposed to be bio resistant, leaks like crazy at the hose tails ... can't workout why, but the PU water pipe compression joints are perfect.

Mine started to leak recently at the end where the hose tail for the nozzle is fixed into it.
I just cut off six inches of hose, refitted the tail and all is fine again.

I wonder if the jubilee clip damages the PU liner?
Interestingly the other end, which also has a hose tail into a 3/4" valve but never moves is fine, only the end which is always being flexed near the nozzle started to leak

Glad I'm not the only one!

I've tried cutting off the ends, but still the same.

I thought perhaps the barbs on the hose tail were cutting the liner, so I changed them for 22mm copper (obviously smooth) ... still the same.  I'm not using jubilee clips. I used hydraulic hose clips all same this ...

(http://www.hcl-clamping.co.uk/cw4/images/product_full/l-bolt-barrel.jpg)


in the futile hope they would be less prone to leaking.

I'd love to know what the problem is as I have a completely bio tight delivery system from the shed to the car with the exception of this frigging hose.

I might try sending  Oily Bits and email and see if they have any suggestions.  I'll mention that two members have had similar problems ... anyone else had similar issues to add strength to the enquiry?

Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Julian on September 15, 2014, 08:16:34 PM
Before rushing out to buy iron or plastic pipe and fittings I thought of trying an experiment.

11 days ago I put a copper fitting into some bio and also a copper fitting into some wvo.
In the picture the wvo on the right started turning green within a day and now is very green and if I lift out the fitting it has slime on it.
The bio in the centre has a very very slight hint of green after 11 days.
The jar on the left contains bio from the same batch as centre jar but with nothing in it so colours can be compared.


Interesting experiment, not sure I've heard of anyone doing it before.

It would be a great photo for the wiki.  Would you mind taking a few more over time and uploading them?  We can then find or create a page for them.

I had some info from a mate with a chemistry PhD on the effect of methanol on aluminium which is posted somewhere ... perhaps we could have a materials compatibility page.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Soft top on September 15, 2014, 11:56:08 PM


[/quote]


Interesting experiment, not sure I've heard of anyone doing it before.

It would be a great photo for the wiki.  Would you mind taking a few more over time and uploading them?  We can then find or create a page for them.

I had some info from a mate with a chemistry PhD on the effect of methanol on aluminium which is posted somewhere ... perhaps we could have a materials compatibility page.

[/quote]

Yep. Im happy to do that. In fact this evening I got some bio from the same batch and dropped a brass fitting into it to see what happens..........
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Tony on September 19, 2014, 09:15:11 PM
Brass seems to turn a very golden yellow when submerged.  I guess it too will stain the bio with a green effect.
I wonder what it is they put in Brasso to make it clean the oxidised layer of copper?  Maybe we're missing a trick, we should be selling bio-based copper cleaning solutions :)
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: K.H on September 19, 2014, 10:21:14 PM
I tested a some different things a few years ago, over a six month period incl copper brass and a few various plastics, i posted the results on the VOD so i guess they are long gone.
It would be good if Soft top does it and posts the results

(http://i316.photobucket.com/albums/mm323/KRH01/Bioexperiment002.jpg)

(http://i316.photobucket.com/albums/mm323/KRH01/Bioexperiment001.jpg)

(http://i316.photobucket.com/albums/mm323/KRH01/Bioexperiment004.jpg)

(http://i316.photobucket.com/albums/mm323/KRH01/Bioexperiment003.jpg)
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Julian on September 19, 2014, 11:00:36 PM
I have some printed samples of PLA sitting in bio and methanol.  I'll take some photos and make a few notes ... just can't remember how long ago I set them up!
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: julianf on September 19, 2014, 11:29:40 PM
re: brass

isnt DZR brass supposed to be better in chemicals?


Wikipedia -

Quote
Corrosion-resistant brass for harsh environments[edit]

Brass sampling cock with stainless steel handle.
The so-called dezincification resistant (DZR or DR) brasses, sometimes referred to as CR (corrosion resistant) brasses, are used where there is a large corrosion risk and where normal brasses do not meet the standards. Applications with high water temperatures, chlorides present, or deviating water qualities (soft water) play a role. DZR-brass is excellent in water boiler systems. This brass alloy must be produced with great care, with special attention placed on a balanced composition and proper production temperatures and parameters to avoid long-term failures.

No mention of bio and veg oil though.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: Soft top on September 29, 2014, 07:57:16 PM
After 26 days........
From the left,
1. Bio with nothing in for reference.
2. Bio from same batch. Has a very slight hint of green which appeared within 2 days of inserting fitting but did not increase after that.
3. WVO. Went very green within a few days. It looks a bit clearer now but there is green slime on bottom of jar and on the fitting.
4. After my last post (11 days ago) I put a brass fitting into bio from the same batch. No change.

After looking at the samples I am happy to use the copper that I have. The bio that will be standing in the pipes will be from batches with a clear pass and will only sit in the pipes for a max of 2 weeks at a time. It seems that green slime is produced from something in wvo.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: rbdazza on September 29, 2014, 08:48:40 PM
For what its worth I have a mixture of copper pipe and 'plastic' pipe on the bottom of my storage tank which have had bio sat inside them for over a year (obviously the bio is continually refreshed but they are always full) and the bio comes out the nozzle crystal clear still.
Title: Re: Copper or iron pipe?
Post by: slabster on April 19, 2015, 05:50:26 PM
The main issue of material compatibility is the effect on the product. Worth testing the fuel I think.

Slabs